Kalshi New York restraining order hearing: a state judge takes up the attorney general's request on Monday as Kalshi warns of a nationwide halt

This follows our explainer on whether Kalshi is legal in New York. The picture in every state is in the Kalshi legality tracker.
What happened
New York sued Kalshi in state court in July. ABC News reports that the suit accuses the platform of breaking state laws that prohibit betting on games involving New York college teams and all sports betting by people under 21. Kalshi moved the case to federal court. This week U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick rejected the company's arguments for keeping it there and sent it back to Crane.
The attorney general's office then filed a proposed temporary restraining order. As described by The Block, it would bar Kalshi from operating an unlicensed gambling business within or from New York, or to people in New York. It covers contracts on sports, culture, elections and other events, and it would also stop users under 21 from trading and end advertising on college campuses.
The words "from New York" are the center of the fight. Kalshi lawyer Sean Murphy of Milbank wrote to Crane on Thursday night that because the company is based in the state, the order would in effect close its federally regulated exchange to all customers and would likely force the liquidation of every open position. Kalshi also argues that the order conflicts with an August 11 emergency order from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission directing it to keep operating.
The federal regulator tried to stop the hearing and failed. On Friday, November 20, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied the CFTC's emergency request from the bench after a telephone hearing. According to the attorney general's office, she found the agency had not shown it was likely to succeed on its claim that federal commodities law overrides state gaming law. It was the CFTC's second failed emergency bid in New York. Judge Jed Rakoff turned down the first on July 31.
James's office answered Kalshi on Friday. It told the court it is not trying to close the exchange for all customers everywhere, and that the order would not prevent Kalshi from offering lawful futures or swaps. A lawyer for the state, Kate Rhodes Janofsky, argued that Kalshi had submitted no evidence of irreparable harm or market disruption, ABC News reported. The office also asked Crane to give the CFTC's August order no weight.
Kalshi's public line, given to CoinDesk, is that it has been a federally regulated exchange since the previous administration certified it, and that it wants to work with the governor and the attorney general on a resolution that protects what it counts as 1.2 million New York users.
What the market is pricing
There is no listed contract on Monday's ruling that we could read, so the closest market signals are indirect. Share prices are Friday closes from Twelve Data. The Polymarket quote is from its public API at about 16:13 UTC on November 22.
| Indicator | Latest | Change | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polymarket: Supreme Court accepts a sports event contract case by December 31, 2026 | About 2.5% Yes (last trade 1.5%) | 1.9% at our November 21 reading | About $175,000 traded on this contract |
| DraftKings (DKNG), Friday close | $15.80 | -6.06% | Session low of $15.77 is the 52-week low |
| Flutter (FLUT), Friday close | $67.19 | -1.80% | 52-week low is $66.97 |
| Federal appeals courts on state power over Kalshi | 3 for states, 1 for Kalshi | Fourth Circuit added this week | Fourth, Sixth and Ninth against the Third |
Two cautions on reading the table. The sportsbook share prices fell during a week of broad selling in US stocks, so the moves cannot be pinned on the Kalshi litigation. And the Polymarket contract is a question about the calendar. It asks whether the justices accept a case before year end, which is a narrow window whatever happens in Manhattan on Monday.
Why it matters
Earlier state wins against Kalshi led to geographic blocks. Users in those states lost access and everyone else carried on. New York is different because the company runs its exchange from there. If a court order reaches activity from New York and not only activity aimed at New Yorkers, the argument over where one state's authority ends becomes an argument about the whole venue. That is the scenario Kalshi and the CFTC describe, and the one the state says it is not pursuing.
The wider legal ground has also moved toward the states. The Fourth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in the Maryland case this week, making it three federal appeals courts for the states and one, the Third Circuit, for Kalshi. The judges on the states' side do not share a single reasoning, which is one reason lawyers expect the question to reach the Supreme Court. Attorney Daniel Wallach wrote on Saturday that if Crane adopts the "from New York" language, the dispute could land on the Court's emergency docket, The Block reported.
Licensed sportsbooks have a stake as well. They pay state taxes and license fees for the same sports customers that event contracts reach without a state license. Our earlier report on the DraftKings and Flutter selloff covers that overlap.
What to watch next
First, Monday at 11:30 a.m. ET. Crane can grant the order, deny it, narrow its wording or reserve decision. The treatment of the "from New York" language matters as much as the yes or no.
Second, the federal case. The CFTC and the Justice Department sued New York in April, and the agency's request for a preliminary injunction has been pending before Schofield since May, according to The Block. A ruling there could change the footing of the state case.
Third, December 7, when Kalshi's response to New Jersey's Supreme Court petition is due, as covered in our Supreme Court timeline explainer. Prices on questions that both venues list are on the Kalshi vs Polymarket odds page.
LIVE MARKETHow many Fed rate cuts in 2026?Trade on Polymarket →Related
- Kalshi legality tracker, state by state
- Is Kalshi legal in New York?
- Fourth Circuit rules 2-1 for Maryland against Kalshi
- Will the Supreme Court take the Kalshi case?
- Louisiana restraining order on Kalshi and Polymarket
- Kalshi vs Polymarket odds, live
Frequently asked questions
When is the Kalshi New York restraining order hearing?
The hearing is set for Monday, November 23, 2026 at 11:30 a.m. ET (16:30 UTC) before Justice Melissa Crane in New York County Supreme Court, according to The Block. As of Sunday, November 22, no restraining order had been granted.
Would the New York order shut down Kalshi nationwide?
That is disputed. Kalshi and the CFTC told the courts that an order covering activity from New York would halt the exchange for every customer because the company is headquartered there. The attorney general's office says it is not seeking to close the exchange everywhere and that lawful futures and swaps would not be affected.
What do prediction markets say about the Supreme Court taking the Kalshi question?
As of about 16:13 UTC on November 22, 2026, the Polymarket contract on the Supreme Court accepting a sports event contract case by December 31, 2026 was quoted near 2.5% Yes, with a last trade of 1.5%. That is a price on the year-end deadline only, not a prediction.
Sources
- The Block, Kalshi faces Monday hearing on New York order it says would shut down its exchange nationwide
- ABC News, report on the restraining order request and Friday federal rulings
- CoinDesk, Kalshi races to get ahead of New York order that could shut down exchange
- Polymarket, SCOTUS accepts sports event contract case market, read about 16:13 UTC via the public Polymarket API
- Twelve Data, DKNG and FLUT closing quotes for November 20, 2026
Market prices, not predictions or advice. 18+. This page reports market prices and published facts; it is not betting, financial or legal advice. If gambling stops being fun, help is available at 1-800-GAMBLER.