Kalshi Maryland Fourth Circuit ruling: a split panel sides with the state 2-1, and Polymarket still prices a Supreme Court pickup this year at 1.8%

This updates our explainer on whether Kalshi is legal in Maryland, which was written while the appeal was still pending. The national picture is in the Kalshi legality tracker.
What happened
The dispute began last year, when Maryland regulators sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter demanding that it stop offering what the state considers unlicensed sports wagering. Kalshi sued in federal court and asked for an injunction, arguing that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission has exclusive jurisdiction over contracts listed on a federally registered exchange. In August 2025 the district court in Maryland refused, the first time a federal court had sided with a state on sports event contracts. Kalshi appealed, the Fourth Circuit heard argument on May 7, 2026, and Maryland agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against the company while the appeal was pending.
The answer came in a short unsigned opinion that says only that the district court's judgment is affirmed, according to the trade publication InGame. The reasoning is in three separate opinions.
Judge Roger Gregory wrote that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt state gambling law. He rejected both of Kalshi's preemption theories and did not decide whether sports contracts are swaps. Reuters quoted him as writing that Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to.
Judge Stephanie Thacker took a different route to the same outcome. She concluded that sports event contracts are not swaps in the first place, reasoning that the result of a game is an outcome and not an occurrence in the sense the statute uses, InGame reported.
Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented. She would have held that the contracts are swaps and that federal law preempts state law, placing them under the CFTC alone.
Both sides claimed something. Jeremy Baker, acting director of Maryland's lottery and gaming regulator, welcomed the decision and said it affirmed the state's ability to regulate sports wagering, according to Reuters. Kalshi called the decision splintered and said three opinions that disagree with each other show there is no unified legal argument against prediction markets.
What the market is pricing
The price below is from the public Polymarket API, read at about 01:10 UTC on November 18. Earlier readings are from our September explainer on the Supreme Court timeline.
| Polymarket contract | Yes price | Change | Earlier reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supreme Court accepts a sports event contract case by December 31, 2026 | 1.8% | -28.2 pts in one month | 46% on September 3; 58% peak in late August |
| Same question, by October 31, 2026 | Resolved No | Closed | |
| Same question, by July 31, 2026 | Resolved No | Closed |
A ruling that deepens a circuit split would normally be read as raising the chance of Supreme Court review, and Reuters framed it that way. The contract did not respond, and the reason is the calendar, not the merits. This market asks whether the Court accepts a case by December 31. New Jersey's petition over the Third Circuit decision is the vehicle already at the Court, and Kalshi's response to it is not due until December 7, InGame reported. That leaves little more than three weeks for briefing to close and for the justices to act. The December 31 contract has traded about $175,000, and the whole event about $1.15 million.
So the 1.8% is a price on timing. It says nothing about whether the Court takes the question in 2027, and there is no live Polymarket contract in this event that covers a later date.
Why it matters
The scoreboard among appeals courts is now three to one. The Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi in the New Jersey case in April. The Ninth Circuit ruled against it in Nevada's case in August, the Sixth Circuit has also sided with a state, and the Fourth Circuit makes three. Our earlier coverage is in the report on the Ninth Circuit ruling.
The courts on the states' side do not agree on why, and that is the part Kalshi is pointing to. Gregory relied on preemption, Thacker on the definition of a swap. Per InGame's summary, the Ninth Circuit found sports contracts fall outside the swap definition for a different reason than Thacker gave. A split within the winning side is also the kind of disagreement the Supreme Court exists to resolve.
The practical effects are closer to home. Maryland's standstill lasted only until the appeal was decided, so the state is now free to move, and InGame reported it may sue in state court to stop the contracts. The Fourth Circuit also covers Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina and West Virginia, where the ruling may give regulators a clearer path to act against sports contracts, InGame noted. Nevada, Michigan, Washington and Louisiana have already won injunctions that forced exchanges to block users there.
That collides with the federal regulator. The CFTC, which backs Kalshi's reading of the law, has told exchanges to stop geofencing states within 30 days or explain why they cannot, according to InGame, and it is unclear how that instruction applies when a court order requires the block.
What to watch next
First, Kalshi's next step in this case. It can ask the full Fourth Circuit to rehear the appeal or go to the Supreme Court. It has not said which.
Second, December 7, when Kalshi's response to New Jersey's petition is due. After that the petition can be scheduled for the justices to consider.
Third, Maryland itself. A state court filing or a new enforcement notice would be the first concrete consequence of the ruling. Live prices on the questions both venues list are on our Kalshi vs Polymarket odds page.
LIVE MARKETHow many Fed rate cuts in 2026?Trade on Polymarket →Related
- Kalshi legality tracker, state by state
- Is Kalshi legal in Maryland?
- Will the Supreme Court take the Kalshi case?
- The Ninth Circuit ruling and nine states
- Kalshi vs Polymarket odds, live
Frequently asked questions
What did the Fourth Circuit rule in the Kalshi Maryland case?
On November 17, 2026 a Fourth Circuit panel voted 2-1 to affirm the denial of Kalshi's request for an injunction against Maryland gaming regulators. The state can pursue enforcement over Kalshi's sports event contracts, according to Reuters and InGame.
Is Kalshi banned in Maryland now?
Not by this ruling alone. The decision removes the obstacle to state enforcement, and Maryland had agreed to hold off only until the appeal was decided. InGame reported that the state may now sue in state court to stop the sports contracts.
Will the Supreme Court take the Kalshi case?
Nobody knows. New Jersey's petition is pending and Kalshi's response is due December 7, 2026. Polymarket priced the Court accepting a sports event contract case by December 31, 2026 at 1.8% at about 01:10 UTC on November 18, which is a price on that deadline only.
Sources
- Reuters via Investing.com, Kalshi loses bid to prevent Maryland from policing prediction market
- InGame, Fourth Circuit rules for Maryland in Kalshi case
- Polymarket, SCOTUS accepts sports event contract case market, read about 01:10 UTC via the public Polymarket API
Market prices, not predictions or advice. 18+. This page reports market prices and published facts; it is not betting, financial or legal advice. If gambling stops being fun, help is available at 1-800-GAMBLER.